(From the Attorney General's
office)
See also the:
Idaho Open
Meeting Law Manual [PDF]
How
to object to a closed meeting
Open Meetings Law
Q: What public bodies or
agencies are subject to the Open Meeting Law?
A: Idaho Code section 67-2342(1)
provides: "All meetings of a governing body of a
public agency shall be open to the public and all persons
shall be permitted to attend any meeting except as
otherwise provided by this act."
"Governing body"
is defined by section 67-2341(5) to mean the members of
any public agency "with the authority to make
decisions for or recommendations to a public agency
regarding any matter." Section 67-2341(4) then
defines "public agency" to encompass various
categories of governmental entities and subdivisions at
all levels of government.
Q: What constitutes a
meeting under the Open Meeting Law?
A: Section 67-2341(6)
defines "meeting" to mean "the convening
of a governing body of a public agency to make a decision
or to deliberate toward a decision on any matter."
"Decision" is then
defined by section 67-2341(1) to include: "...any
determination, action, vote or final disposition upon a
motion, proposal, resolution, order, ordinance or measure
on which a vote of a governing body is required, at any
meeting at which a quorum is present."
The term "deliberation"
is defined by section 67-2341(2) and means "the
receipt or exchange of information or opinion relating to
a decision, but shall not include informal or impromptu
discussions of a general nature which do not specifically
relate to a matter then pending before the public agency
for decision."
Q: What are the notice
requirements of the Open Meeting Law?
A: Section 67-2343 requires
that no less than a five (5) calendar day meeting notice
will be given unless otherwise provided by statute. With
respect to "special meetings" or "executive
sessions," there must be at least a twenty-four (24)
hour meeting notice, unless an emergency exists.
The notice of an executive
session must state the authorizing provision of law.
The notice requirement of section 67-2343 also includes
the requirement of posting an agenda. With respect to
"regular meetings," a forty-eight (48) hour
advance agenda notice is required. New agenda items
cannot be added unless it can be shown that a good faith
effort has been made to include in the published notice
all agenda items known at the time to be probable items
of discussion. The notice must specifically set forth the
purpose of the meeting and "items of business."
Q: Are public agencies
required to hold executive sessions?
A: No. It should be noted
that the Open Meeting Law establishes circumstances where
executive sessions are permissible. The act in no way
requires any closed meetings. The Idaho Attorney
General's office advises: If in doubt, open the meeting.
The Law
THE ACT
(Idaho Code §§
67-2340 through 67-2347)
67-2340.
Formation of public policy at open meetings. -- The
people of the
state of Idaho in
creating the instruments of government that serve them,
do
not yield their
sovereignty to the agencies so created. Therefore, the
Legislature finds
and
declares that it is
the policy of this state that the formation of public
policy is public
business and shall not be conducted in secret.
67-2341. Open
public meetings Definitions. -- As used in this act:
(1) "Decision"
means any determination, action, vote or final
disposition upon
a motion, proposal,
resolution, order, ordinance or measure on which a vote
of
a governing body is
required, at any meeting at which a quorum is present,
but
shall not include
those ministerial or administrative actions necessary to
carry out a
decision previously adopted in a meeting held in
compliance with
sections 67-2342
through 67-2346, Idaho Code.
(2) "Deliberation"
means the receipt or exchange of information or opinion
relating to a
decision, but shall not include informal or impromptu
discussions
of a general nature
which do not specifically relate to a matter then pending
before the public
agency for decision.
(3) "Executive
session" means any meeting or part of a meeting of a
governing
body which is
closed to any persons for deliberation on certain matters.
(4) "Public
agency" means:
(a) any state
board, commission, department, authority, educational
institution
or other state
agency which is created by or pursuant to statute, other
than
courts and their
agencies and divisions, and the judicial council, and the
district
magistrates commission;
(b) any regional
board, commission, department or authority created by or
pursuant to
statute;
(c) any county,
city, school district, special district, or other
municipal
corporation or
political subdivision of the state of Idaho;
(d) any
subagency of a public agency which is created by or
pursuant to
statute, ordinance,
or other legislative act.
(5) "Governing
body" means the members of any public agency which
consists of
two (2) or more
members, with the authority to make decisions for or
recommendations to
a public agency regarding any matter.
(6) "Meeting"
means the convening of a governing body of a public
agency to
make a decision or
to deliberate toward a decision on any matter.
(a) "regular
meeting" means the convening of a governing body of
a public
agency on the date
fixed by law or rule, to conduct the business of the
agency.
(b) "special
meeting" is a convening of the governing body of a
public agency
pursuant to a
special call for the conduct of business as specified in
the
call.
67-2342.
Governing bodies Requirement for open public meetings.
(1) Except as
provided below, all meetings of a governing body of a
public
agency shall be
open to the public and all persons shall be permitted to
attend
any meeting except
as otherwise provided by this act. No decision at a
meeting
of a governing body
of a public agency shall be made by secret ballot.
(2)
Deliberations of the board of tax appeals created in
chapter 38, title 63,
Idaho Code, the
public utilities commission and the industrial commission
in a
fully submitted
adjudicatory proceeding in which hearings, if any are
required,
have been
completed, and in which the legal rights, duties or
privileges of a
party are to be
determined are not required by this act to take place in
a
meeting open to the
public. Such deliberations may, however, be made and/or
conducted in a
public meeting at the discretion of the agency.
(3) A governing
body shall not hold a meeting at any place where
discrimination
on the basis of
race, creed, color, sex, age or national origin is
practiced.
67-2343. Notice
of meetings.
(1) Regular
meetings. No less than a five (5) calendar day meeting
notice shall
be given unless
otherwise provided by statute. Provided however,
that any
public agency that
holds meetings at regular intervals of at least once per
calendar month
scheduled in advance over the course of the year may
satisfy
this meeting notice
by giving meeting notices at least once each year of its
regular meeting
schedule. A fortyeight (48) hour agenda notice shall be
required in advance
of each regular meeting, however, additional agenda items
may be added after
completion of the agenda up to and including the hour of
the
meeting, provided
that a good faith effort is made to include in the notice
all
agenda items known
at the time to be probable items of discussion. The
notice
requirement for
meetings and agendas shall be satisfied by posting such
notices
and agendas in a
prominent place at the principal office of the public
agency,
or if no such
office exists, at the building where the meeting is to be
held.
(2) Special
meetings. No special meeting shall be held without at
least a
twentyfour (24)
hour meeting and agenda notice, unless an emergency
exists. An
emergency is a
situation involving injury or damage to persons or
property, or
immediate financial
loss, or the likelihood of such injury, damage or loss,
when the notice
requirements of this section would make such notice
impracticable, or
increase the likelihood or severity of such injury,
damage or
loss, and the
reason for the emergency is stated at the outset of the
meeting.
The notice required
under this section shall include at a minimum the meeting
date, time, place
and name of the public agency calling for the meeting.
The
secretary or other
designee of each public agency shall maintain a list of
the
news media
requesting notification of meetings and shall make a good
faith
effort to provide
advance notification to them of the time and place of
each
meeting.
(3) Executive
sessions. If an executive session only will be held, a
twenty
four (24) hour
meeting and agenda notice shall be given according to the
notice
provisions stated
in subsection (2) of this section and shall state the
reason
and the specific
provision of law authorizing the executive session.
67-2344. Written
minutes of meetings.
(1) The
governing body of a public agency shall provide for the
taking of
written minutes of
all its meetings. Neither a full transcript nor a
recording
of the meeting is
required, except as otherwise provided by law. All
minutes
shall be available
to the public within a reasonable time after the meeting,
and shall include
at least the following information:
(a) All members
of the governing body present;
(b) All motions,
resolutions, orders, or ordinances proposed and their
disposition;
(c) The results
of all votes, and upon the request of a member, the vote
of
each member, by
name;
(2) Minutes of
executive sessions may be limited to material the
disclosure of
which is not
inconsistent with the provisions of section 67-2345,
Idaho Code,
but shall contain
sufficient detail to convey the general tenor of the
meeting.
67-2345.
Executive sessions When authorized.
(1) Nothing
contained in this act shall be construed to prevent, upon
a
twothirds (2/3)
vote recorded in the minutes of the meeting by individual
vote,
a governing body of
a public agency from holding an executive session during
any meeting, after
the presiding officer has identified the authorization
under
this act for the
holding of such executive session. An executive session
may be
held:
(a) To consider
hiring a public officer, employee, staff member or
individual
agent. This
paragraph does not apply to filling a vacancy in an
elective
office;
(b) To consider
the evaluation, dismissal or disciplining of, or to hear
complaints or
charges brought against, a public officer, employee,
staff member
or individual
agent, or public school student;
(c) To conduct
deliberations concerning labor negotiations or to acquire
an
interest in real
property which is not owned by a public agency;
(d) To consider
records that are exempt from disclosure as provided in
chapter
3, title 9, Idaho
Code;
(e) To consider
preliminary negotiations involving matters of trade or
commerce
in which the
governing body is in competition with governing bodies in
other
states or nations;
(f) To consider
and advise its legal representatives in pending
litigation or
where there is a
general public awareness of probable litigation;
(g) By the
commission of pardons and parole, as provided by law.
(2) Labor
negotiations may be conducted in executive session if
either side
requests closed
meetings. Notwithstanding the provisions of section 67-2343,
Idaho Code,
subsequent sessions of the negotiations may continue
without
further public
notice.
(3) No executive
session may be held for the purpose of taking any final
action
or making any final
decision.
67-2346. Open
legislative meetings required. -- All meetings of any
standing,
special or select
committee of either house of the Legislature of the state
of
Idaho shall be open
to the public at all times, and any person may attend any
meeting of a
standing, special or select committee, but may
participate in the
committee only with
the approval of the committee itself.
67-2347.
Violations.
(1) If an
action, or any deliberation or decisionmaking that leads
to an
action, occurs at
any meeting which fails to comply with the provisions of
sections 67-2340
through 67-2346, Idaho Code, such action shall be null
and
void.
(2) Any member
of the governing body governed by the provisions of
sections
67-2340 through 67-2346,
Idaho Code, who knowingly conducts or participates in
a meeting which
violates the provisions of this act shall be subject to a
fine
not to exceed one
hundred fifty dollars ($150) for a first violation and
not to
exceed three
hundred dollars ($300) for each subsequent violation as a
civil
penalty.
(3) The attorney
general shall have the duty to enforce this act in
relation to
public agencies of
state government, and the prosecuting attorneys of the
various counties
shall have the duty to enforce this act in relation to
local
public agencies
within their respective jurisdictions. In the event that
there
is reason to
believe that a violation of the provisions of this act
has been
committed by
members of a board of county commissioners or, for any
other
reason a county
prosecuting attorney is deemed disqualified from
proceeding to
enforce this act,
the prosecuting attorney or board of county commissioners
shall seek to have
a special
prosecutor appointed for that purpose as provided in
section 31-2603,
Idaho Code.
(4) Any person
affected by a violation of the provisions of this act may
commence a civil
action in the magistrate division of the district court
of the
county in which the
public agency ordinarily meets, for the purpose of
requiring
compliance with provisions of this act. No private action
brought
pursuant to this
subsection shall result in the assessment of a civil
penalty
against any
member of a public
agency and there shall be no private right of action for
damages arising out
of any violation of the provisions of sections 67-2342
through 67-2346,
Idaho Code. Any suit brought for the purpose of having an
action declared or
determined to be null and void pursuant to subsection (1)
of
this section shall
be commenced within thirty (30) days of the time of the
violation or
alleged violation of the provisions of this act. Any
other suit
brought under the
provisions of this section shall be commenced within one
hundred eighty (180)
days of the time of the violation or alleged violation of
the provisions of
this act.
|